New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream

Nestled in the heart of Hartville, Ohio, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is a charming ice cream shop that truly captures the spirit of old-fashioned, homemade desserts. This beloved local gem invites ice cream enthusiasts to indulge in generous, handcrafted scoops of rich, creamy goodness made fresh on-site every day. Whether you’re stopping by after a day at the Hartville Flea Market or unwinding near the nearby campground, this is the perfect destination to satisfy your sweet tooth.

The magic of New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream lies in its unique, ever-changing flavor lineup that keeps patrons coming back for more. Fans rave about classic favorites and innovative combinations alike, from the luscious butterscotch and butter pecan to the vibrant Blue Moon and refreshing orange pineapple cones. The generous portions alone make your visit worthwhile — many customers admit that even a “small” size is plenty to share, while the waffle cones, crispy and perfectly toasted, add a delightful crunch that complements the velvety texture of the ice cream.

One of the standout experiences, as described by longtime customer Michael Lee, was their peanut butter sundae. Layered with chocolate ice cream, hot fudge, Reese’s cup bits, nuts, whipped cream, and topped with a cherry, it’s a decadent treat that echoes the nostalgic flavors of a Friendly’s sundae but with that unmistakable homemade touch. Others, like Steve Karl and Steve Metz, highlight both the quality and speed of service—there’s rarely a long wait, even on busy days, and friendly staff ensure that every order is delivered with a smile.

The atmosphere at New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is casual and inviting—a perfect stop for families, couples, or solo travelers looking to enjoy a comforting, sweet moment. Despite its popularity and bustling parking lot, the staff efficiently manage the flow of customers through a two-window system: one for ordering and another for pickup, allowing you to quickly savor your treat without unnecessary delay.

What truly makes this ice cream shop stand out is not just the quality of its offerings but the sense of community it fosters. Regulars like Toni Cooper eagerly follow their Facebook page to keep up with the rotating flavors, ensuring each visit feels fresh and exciting. Danny Robinson’s praise for the portions and the waffle cones echoes a universal sentiment—this is a place where quality meets generosity in every scoop.

In essence, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is more than just a spot to cool down on a hot day. It’s a destination where tradition meets creativity, where every bite is infused with care, and where your cravings for rich, homemade ice cream will undoubtedly be fulfilled. Whether you're a local or just passing through Hartville, this charming shop deserves a prominent place on your list of must-try sweet treats.